Manchester City vs Newcastle United Carabao Cup Semi-final: Predicted Lineups, Team News & Injury Updates

The stage is set for a blockbuster night at the Etihad Stadium as Manchester City host Newcastle United in the second leg of the Carabao Cup (also known as the EFL Cup) semi-final. With City holding a 2–0 lead from the first leg at St James’ Park, this tie is far from finished. History tells us that cup football can twist in the blink of an eye — especially when the prize is a trip to Wembley Stadium.

For fans of tactics, drama, and late-night nerves, this match has everything: injury crises, tactical chess, star names, and the looming shadow of a cup final. Below is a deep, fan-friendly breakdown of match context, team news, predicted lineups, tactical battles, key players, and what each team must do step by step to reach Wembley.

The Big Picture: Why This Tie Matters

Manchester City are going through a rare season of uncertainty. After years of dominance in the Premier League under Pep Guardiola, their league title hopes look fragile, sitting six points behind Arsenal.

Because of this, many pundits believe Guardiola may now prioritize domestic cups — especially if this is his final season at the club. Winning the Carabao Cup would keep silverware flowing and maintain City’s aura of inevitability in knockout competitions.

On the other side, Newcastle United, the defending Carabao Cup champions, are desperate to keep their trophy defense alive. Eddie Howe’s men are wounded but not defeated — and two goals in football can disappear surprisingly fast.

Match Snapshot

• Kick-off: 8 p.m. GMT

• Venue: Etihad Stadium

• Competition: Carabao Cup Semi-final (Second Leg)

• Aggregate score: Manchester City 2–0 Newcastle United

• Recent City form: LLWWD

How We Got Here (A Quick Story)

Three weeks ago at St James’ Park, City stunned the crowd with clinical finishing from Antoine Semenyo and Rayan Cherki.

Newcastle dominated possession at times, hit the woodwork, and looked dangerous — but City were ruthless on the break. Many Magpies fans left that night saying: “We played well… but lost.” That’s the cruel beauty of cup football.

Now, the tie shifts to Manchester — a place where Newcastle historically struggle.

Team News & Injury Updates

Manchester City – Team News

City are dealing with a significant injury list:

Out:

• Marc Guéhi — ineligible (signed after first leg)

• Jérémy Doku — calf injury

• Rúben Dias — hamstring

• Joško Gvardiol — tibial fracture

• John Stones — thigh

• Mateo Kovačić — ankle/heel

• Savinho — unspecified issue

Doubtful:

• None officially — but fitness of some returning players remains unclear.

Guardiola confirmed that Doku will not return for this game, which is bad news for Erling Haaland, who often thrives on Doku’s deliveries.

Newcastle United – Team News

Newcastle’s injury list is just as worrying:

Out:

• Tino Livramento — hamstring

• Emil Krafth — knee

• Fabian Schär — ankle

• Joelinton — groin

• Bruno Guimarães — ankle

• Lewis Miley — knee

Doubtful:

• Sven Botman — thigh

Without Bruno Guimarães, Newcastle lose their midfield heartbeat — a huge blow in a game where control will be vital.

Predicted Lineups

Manchester City Predicted Lineup (4-2-2-2)

GK: James Trafford
RB: Rico Lewis
CB: Abdukodir Khusanov
CB: Nathan Aké
LB: Nico O’Reilly

CM: Nico González
CM: Bernardo Silva

AM: Phil Foden
AM: Rayan Cherki

ST: Antoine Semenyo
ST: Erling Haaland

Why this makes sense:
City will look to control possession, invite pressure, and hit Newcastle on the counter with Haaland’s pace and Semenyo’s movement.

Newcastle United Predicted Lineup (4-3-3)

GK: Nick Pope
RB: Kieran Trippier
CB: Thiaw
CB: Dan Burn
LB: Lewis Hall

CM: Joe Willock
CM: Sandro Tonali
CM: Jacob Murphy

RW: Anthony Gordon
ST: Yoane Wissa
LW: Harvey Barnes

Why this works:
Newcastle must attack — so pace on the wings (Gordon and Barnes) will be crucial.

Tactical Battle: How This Game Will Play Out

City’s Plan (Step-by-Step Guide)

1. Slow the tempo in the first 15 minutes.

2. Keep the ball with Rodri-style control via Nico González.

3. Draw Newcastle out, then release Haaland behind their defense.

4. Defend set pieces carefully — Newcastle are dangerous here.

5. Kill the game with a late goal if possible.

Newcastle’s Plan (Step-by-Step Guide)

1. Press high from kickoff.

2. Target City’s full-backs (Rico Lewis and O’Reilly).

3. Win corners and free kicks — this is their best weapon.

4. Score before halftime to change the tie.

5. Push numbers forward in the final 20 minutes.

Key Players to Watch

Erling Haaland (Manchester City)

If Haaland scores, the tie is over. If he misses chances, Newcastle will believe.

Rayan Cherki (Manchester City)

His dribbling could slice through Newcastle’s defense.

Sandro Tonali (Newcastle)

Must control midfield in Bruno’s absence.

Anthony Gordon (Newcastle)

Fast, tricky, and dangerous on the break.

A Quick Anecdote: Cup Nights Are Crazy

In 2014, Newcastle nearly shocked City in a cup tie at the Etihad — scoring early and rattling the champions. City eventually recovered, but that night proved one thing: when Newcastle smell blood, they bite.

Expect fireworks.

SportInsiderly Prediction

Manchester City 2–1 Newcastle United
City win 4–1 on aggregate

Newcastle will fight bravely, but City’s quality should carry them to Wembley.

Final Thoughts

This Carabao Cup semi-final is more than just a match — it’s about pride, legacy, and silverware. Whether you back Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City or Eddie Howe’s Newcastle United, one thing is certain: Wednesday night will be unforgettable.

Stay tuned with SportInsiderly for match updates, post-game analysis, and smarter football coverage — because every detail matters.

Recommended Stories:

Kai Havertz’s Last-Gasp Winner Fires Arsenal into the Carabao Cup Final

From San Siro Glory to Tragedy: Ex-Inter Milan Star Dies at 39

8 Footballers SportInsiderly Predicts Will Break Out in 2026

Top 10 Players with the Most International Goals in Football History